top of page

Costume Advice

TINSEL & TROUBLE ROLES

Christmas-Themed Characters for a Holiday Murder Mystery Party

Whether you're a jolly icon, a festive fraud, or a peppermint-scented menace, the Tinsel & Trouble crew brings holiday cheer—with a suspicious amount of drama. These characters sparkle on the surface, but underneath the ugly sweaters and jingling bells, someone’s definitely up to snow good.

EXAMPLE LOOKS OF TINSEL & TROUBLE COSTUMES.

Funny T-Shirt & Hoodie Costumes

costume suggestions & advice

Classic Aesthetic

​​

THE COSTUME: Closet Staples You Might Already Have

Classic Christmas Look:

  • Red, green, silver, or gold clothing

  • Santa hat, elf ears, reindeer antlers, or tinsel headbands

  • Ugly Christmas sweater—louder = better

  • Fuzzy boots or slippers, striped tights, or sparkly heels

  • Accessorize with ornaments, garland, and holiday pins

Elves & Helpers:

  • Tunics or aprons, striped leggings, jingle bells

  • Pointy hat and shoes (DIY with cardboard if needed!)

  • Carry a clipboard or a sack full of "defective" toys

Fancier Characters (Snow Queen, Ghosts, etc.):

  • Flowing robes, dramatic capes, all-white or icy-blue outfits

  • Glitter makeup, white wigs, or fake snow accents

  • Light-up accessories for ghostly glow or regal drama

Modern Characters (Influencer, Mall Staff, etc.):

  • Trendy red jumpsuits or influencer-chic holiday wear

  • Santa suit worn ironically or on a lunch break

  • Apron with “#1 Wrapper” or “Sleigh All Day” printed

 
HAIR & MAKEUP:
  • Add glitter, red lipstick, or frosted highlights

  • Elf freckles made from dots of red or green eyeliner

  • Candy-cane eyeliner or snowflake face stickers

  • For darker characters: smoky eyes with red shimmer, or "frostbite" contouring with blue/gray tones

 
ACCESSORIES: 
  • Candy canes, bells, bows, or wrapped “gifts” with hidden surprises

  • A fake list of naughty names—including other guests

  • Wrapped presents labeled “Evidence,” “Secrets,” or “Don’t Open Til Trial”

  • A toy hammer, snow globe, or suspicious fruitcake

  • Ornament earrings or light-up necklaces

  • A name tag that says “Not The Real Santa (Don’t Ask)”

​​

CHARACTER & ROLEPLAYING TIPS
Voice & Speech
  • Use exaggerated cheer or suspiciously forced joy

  • Elves may talk fast and frantically, like sugar-fueled interns

  • Santa and Mrs. Claus can be sweet or sinisterly soothing

  • Carolers speak in song—or act like they will unless you behave

  • Frosty characters? Cold, calculated, and maybe British

Behavioral Quirks
  • Always jingling from somewhere

  • Handing out “gifts” at random and refusing to explain them

  • Drinking from a mug that says “Ho Ho Homicide”

  • Passive-aggressive to anyone not wearing red

  • Murmuring “it’s beginning to look a lot like vengeance” when the lights dim

 Bonus Touches
  • Wrap clues or items in gift boxes and "accidentally" drop them

  • Pretend to be haunted by a Ghost of Christmas Scandals Past

  • Interrupt conversations with awkward carols (“Deck the halls with DEEP suspicion…”)

  • Leave behind glitter like a festive calling card

  • Claim you were framed—and all you wanted was a silent night

​​

​Tinsel & Trouble characters are merry, bright… and maybe homicidal. Whether you’re jingling all the way to the witness stand or sleighing in style, one thing’s for sure: someone’s getting wrapped up in this mystery.

​

 

 Join our community for the latest mysteries, exclusive deals from the mother ship, and behind-the-scenes looks.

  • X
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • Facebook

© 2006. My Mystery Party, LLC. All rights reserved. Games created by Dr. Bon Blossman.

bottom of page
colorLinks("#0000FF"); function colorLinks(hex) { var links = document.getElementsByTagName("a"); for(var i=0;i