top of page

Costume Advice

CREATIVE CHARACTER ROLES

Whether you’re the tortured painter, the cutthroat gallerist, or the overly expressive design diva, art-world characters are bursting with style, secrets, and a splash of self-importance. These roles are perfect for dramatic flair, subtle sarcasm, and looking suspiciously avant-garde in every room you enter.

EXAMPLE LOOKS OF CREATIVE ROLE COSTUMES.

TYPES OF MURDER MYSTERY PARTY CHARACTERS

You're likely to have been assigned one of the following character roles to play:
  • The Eccentric Fine Artist – Paint-splattered, possibly misunderstood, definitely intense.

  • The Minimalist Interior Designer – Clean lines, sharp tastes, and harsh critiques.

  • The Gallerist or Art Gallery Owner – Wealth-adjacent, always curating both art and gossip.

  • The Art Dealer – Greasy charm, fast talker, possibly fencing stolen masterpieces.

  • The Abstract Sculptor – Speaks in metaphor, works in metal, rarely blinks.

  • The Art Critic – Wields a pen like a dagger, has opinions on everything, and likes no one.

  • The Restoration Expert – Knows what’s underneath the layers—of paint and people.

  • The Installation Artist – Lives in a warehouse, builds things no one understands, possibly leaves behind ominous sculptures.

  • The Art School Dropout – Passionate, broke, and definitely on the edge of something.

  • The Poet - Broke, dramatic, and sees life through extraordinarily detailed gray lenses. 

  • The Museum Guard – Stoic, suspicious, and done with everyone’s nonsense.

  • The Collector – Fancy, controlling, and terrified of fingerprints.

  • The Forger – Too talented for their own good. Keeps saying “It’s not fake, it’s faithful.”

  • The Art Teacher – Encouraging but clearly one coffee away from chaos.

Classic Aesthetic

THE COSTUME: Closet Staples You Might Already Have
  • Start with dramatic pieces or anything that feels deliberately styled—even if it’s mismatched, the goal is to look like you meant it. Artists may wear oversized paint-stained shirts, asymmetrical sweaters, dramatic scarves, and old boots or canvas sneakers. A beret or wide-brimmed hat can push things into comedy territory, if that’s your angle.

  • Designers and gallerists often wear sleek, curated outfits: think black turtlenecks, stylish blazers, slacks, statement dresses, or jumpsuits. Monochrome with a bold accessory or architectural silhouette will sell the designer look. Bonus points for glasses that are purely aesthetic.

  • Art dealers might be a little flashier—wearing patterned suits, gold chains, and polished loafers—especially if they’re shady.

 
HAIR & MAKEUP:
  • Artists often lean toward expressive, undone, or wildly stylized looks. A messy bun with paintbrushes stuck inside? Perfect. Colored streaks? Yes. Smudged eyeliner or dramatic eye shadow adds to the tortured soul vibe.

  • Designers and gallerists tend to be more polished: slick ponytails, tidy bobs, precision makeup with bold lipstick or minimalistic glam. Critics might wear pince-nez or tiny wire glasses low on the nose for maximum condescension.

  • Restoration experts or dealers might have faint dust on their sleeves or gloves tucked into their belts.

 
ACCESSORIES: 

It’s all about the personal statement:

  • A paintbrush tucked behind the ear or a palette in hand

  • Oversized sketchbooks, measuring tape, or mood boards

  • Sunglasses worn indoors (because art is blinding, obviously)

  • Portfolio cases, vintage cameras, or auction catalogs

  • Eccentric jewelry made of random objects (gears, rulers, doll parts)

  • A “gallery name tag” or VIP lanyard that reads:
    “ArtHaus Collective – Curator of Vision” (Or whatever gallery your character works at.)

  • A travel coffee mug that says “Warhol Wouldn’t Approve”

  • Color swatches, a tape measure, or architectural miniatures

​​

🎨 Palette of Peril: A Character Guide for Artists, Aesthetes & Accidental Criminals

Because when art meets mystery, someone’s always dying for attention.

🎨 The Eccentric Fine Artist – The Master of Mayhem

Vibe: Passionate, unpredictable, and convinced the world “just doesn’t get it.”
Paints at midnight. Drinks too much coffee. May have “accidentally” painted over the evidence.

Costume (from your closet):

  • Paint-splattered shirt, scarf, loose jeans, and sneakers.

  • Beret or beanie optional, but dramatic scarf encouraged.

  • Add a streak of color across your face for flair.

Props & Accessories:

  • Paintbrush, sketchbook, or mini canvas labeled “My Darkest Work Yet.”

  • Palette or fake paint tubes.

How to Act:

  • Gaze at people like they’re unfinished portraits.

  • Speak in riddles and dramatic sighs.

  • Start every sentence with “My vision was…”

Quirks:

  • Describes emotions as colors (“I’m feeling… chartreuse”).

  • Waves hands dramatically while talking.

  • Refuses to explain their “process.”

Sayings:

“This murder scene has excellent composition.”
“You can’t arrest inspiration.”
“Art is pain… sometimes literally.”

🪑 The Minimalist Interior Designer – The Chaos Controller

Vibe: Calm, refined, and allergic to clutter. Thinks the color beige is a personality trait.

Costume (from your closet):

  • All neutral tones: black, white, tan, or gray.

  • Crisp shirt, straight-leg pants, tidy hair.

  • One elegant accessory, nothing more.

Props & Accessories:

  • Measuring tape, small ruler, or mood board.

  • Notebook labeled “Less Is More (Except in Murder).”

How to Act:

  • Rearrange things constantly.

  • Speak softly but judge loudly with your eyes.

  • Call every messy space “a creative tragedy.”

Quirks:

  • Straightens crooked objects during conversations.

  • Describes crimes as “overly busy.”

  • Sighs before fixing anything.

Sayings:

“This bloodstain? Overdesigned.”
“Clutter is the enemy of peace — and alibis.”
“I would’ve gone with something… cleaner.”

🖼️ The Gallerist – The Curator of Chaos

Vibe: Polished, poised, and perpetually networking. If there’s gossip, they’ve already framed it.

Costume (from your closet):

  • Stylish blazer, dark jeans or skirt, statement jewelry or watch.

  • Hair neat, confidence untouchable.

Props & Accessories:

  • Clipboard labeled “Private Guest List.”

  • Champagne glass (real or plastic).

How to Act:

  • Drop names of fictional “clients.”

  • Call people “darling” and mean it half the time.

  • Gasp dramatically when someone mentions money.

Quirks:

  • Greets everyone like they’re famous.

  • Walks as if there’s always soft background music.

  • Treats chaos like it’s part of the exhibit.

Sayings:

“Ah, limited edition behavior.”
“We prefer to call it ‘avant-garde crime.’”
“Everything’s for sale… technically.”

💼 The Art Dealer – The Smooth Talker

Vibe: Confident, clever, and just a little too good at getting “exclusive” pieces. Could sell air if it had a signature.

Costume (from your closet):

  • Blazer, turtleneck, or dress shirt.

  • Polished shoes and a confident grin.

  • Pocket square or simple scarf for drama.

Props & Accessories:

  • Folder labeled “Confidential Auction.”

  • Rolled-up “painting” or art catalog.

How to Act:

  • Speak in charming half-truths.

  • Whisper important details, even when unnecessary.

  • Refer to art as “investments.”

Quirks:

  • Checks their watch often.

  • Calls everyone “friend” like it’s a sales pitch.

  • Smiles through everything — even suspicion.

Sayings:

“It’s not stolen, it’s… relocated.”
“Rarity is a state of mind.”
“Supply, demand, and dramatic tension — the golden trio.”

🗿 The Abstract Sculptor – The Quiet Enigma

Vibe: Serious, stoic, and obsessed with form and meaning. Probably welded their emotions years ago.

Costume (from your closet):

  • Work shirt, dark jeans, boots, gloves.

  • Add a few scuff marks for authenticity.

Props & Accessories:

  • Toy hammer or chisel, wire or clay.

  • Notebook labeled “Untitled Ideas.”

How to Act:

  • Speak slowly.

  • Pause too long before answering.

  • Call the murder “an exploration of decay.”

Quirks:

  • Doesn’t blink often.

  • Calls art “structural emotion.”

  • Occasionally hums dramatic music.

Sayings:

“It’s not chaos — it’s kinetic energy.”
“I bend metal, not morals.”
“Art doesn’t explain itself, and neither do I.”

✏️ The Art Critic – The Professional Pessimist

Vibe: Sharp, eloquent, and unimpressed by everything, including the murder.

Costume (from your closet):

  • Blazer or trench coat, scarf, notebook.

  • Glasses (real or fake).

Props & Accessories:

  • Clipboard with “Review Notes.”

  • Red pen and fake press badge.

How to Act:

  • Compliment things sarcastically.

  • Scribble notes mid-conversation.

  • End every insult with “but that’s just my opinion.”

Quirks:

  • Sniffs disdainfully before speaking.

  • Talks in metaphors.

  • Always acts like they’re about to publish a review.

Sayings:

“A bold choice, but not a good one.”
“Your motive? Predictable.”
“This crime scene lacks vision.”

🧴 The Restoration Expert – The Hidden Truth Teller

Vibe: Calm, precise, and quietly unsettling — they see what others try to hide.

Costume (from your closet):

  • Neutral colors, cardigan or lab coat, gloves in pocket.

  • Clean but rumpled look.

Props & Accessories:

  • Small paintbrush, cotton swabs, notebook.

  • Folder labeled “Confidential Findings.”

How to Act:

  • Observe quietly, then drop shocking details.

  • Talk about “layers” — in art and in people.

  • Treat every clue like a priceless relic.

Quirks:

  • Cleans things mid-sentence.

  • Inspects stains a little too closely.

  • Quotes old museum procedures.

Sayings:

“Every surface tells a story.”
“Cracks reveal more than they hide.”
“I’m just restoring the truth.”

🔩 The Installation Artist – The Conceptual Wildcard

Vibe: Visionary, mysterious, and always misunderstood. Believes everything is part of a larger piece — even the crime.

Costume (from your closet):

  • Black jeans, oversized hoodie, boots.

  • Messy bun or unbrushed hair — perfection is boring.

Props & Accessories:

  • Duct tape, rope, notebook labeled “Statement Piece.”

  • Odd prop (like a spoon glued to cardboard).

How to Act:

  • Speak dramatically about meaning.

  • Rearrange objects mid-conversation.

  • Call the murder “immersive art.”

Quirks:

  • Stares off as if picturing invisible sculptures.

  • Adds random words like “transcendence” into sentences.

  • Occasionally whispers, “It’s all part of the experience.”

Sayings:

“The installation began the moment you arrived.”
“Don’t touch that — it’s symbolic.”
“The body? That’s Act Two.”

🎓 The Art School Dropout – The Dreamer

Vibe: Emotional, restless, and very sure the world’s against them.
Lives off coffee, chaos, and creative potential.

Costume (from your closet):

  • Jeans, thrifted jacket, oversized shirt.

  • Sneakers or boots, sketchbook in hand.

Props & Accessories:

  • Coffee cup, crumpled papers, notebook labeled “Someday.”

How to Act:

  • Start passionate rants that go nowhere.

  • Gesture a lot when explaining your “vision.”

  • Interrupt others with big ideas, then forget what you were saying.

Quirks:

  • Constantly doodles.

  • Overreacts to criticism.

  • Quotes teachers no one’s heard of.

Sayings:

“They didn’t expel me — they set me free.”
“Art school couldn’t contain me.”
“One day, they’ll see.”

🖋️ The Poet – The Melancholy Muse

Vibe: Gentle, introspective, and just dramatic enough to make an entrance in slow motion.

Costume (from your closet):

  • Flowing shirt, cardigan, scarf, soft tones.

  • Notebook always nearby.

Props & Accessories:

  • Quill pen (or any pen), journal labeled “Verses of Truth.”

How to Act:

  • Speak softly, sometimes in rhyme.

  • Stare into space before answering.

  • Write mid-conversation.

Quirks:

  • Snaps fingers instead of clapping.

  • Describes everything as “tragic yet beautiful.”

  • Starts poems during tense moments.

Sayings:

“This tragedy… it writes itself.”
“I rhyme in grief and dine in metaphor.”
“My alibi? Inspiration struck.”

🛡️ The Museum Guard – The Unshakable Sentinel

Vibe: Stoic, observant, and 100% done with everyone’s nonsense. Has seen every type of drama imaginable… and refuses to move for any of it.

Costume (from your closet):

  • Navy or gray shirt, black pants, comfortable shoes.

  • Add a badge, name tag, or small radio earpiece.

  • Optional: hat or blazer with “SECURITY” written somewhere.

Props & Accessories:

  • Flashlight, walkie-talkie, fake ID badge, or clipboard labeled “Incident Report.”

  • “Do Not Touch” sign (DIY with paper or cardboard).

How to Act:

  • Stand with arms crossed and watch everyone suspiciously.

  • Speak rarely but with authority.

  • Patrol slowly, like you’re always one step away from telling someone to stop running.

Quirks:

  • Never blinks first.

  • Mutters about “budget cuts.”

  • Treats everyone like they’re breaking museum policy.

Sayings:

“Step away from the exhibit, ma’am.”
“Every masterpiece has fingerprints — yours just might match.”
“I’ve been guarding this place longer than that painting’s been dry.”

💎 The Collector – The Perfectionist Patron

Vibe: Sophisticated, controlling, and dramatically attached to their “curated lifestyle.” Thinks art should be admired from afar — preferably through glass.

Costume (from your closet):

  • Men: Suit jacket or blazer, polished shoes, pocket square.

  • Women: Elegant dress or tailored outfit, pearls or brooch.

  • Both: Gloves — because fingerprints are the enemy.

Props & Accessories:

  • Fake champagne glass, monocle, or rolled-up “auction catalog.”

  • Cloth or handkerchief to “avoid smudging.”

  • Clipboard labeled “Inventory: Priceless.”

How to Act:

  • Speak like you’re narrating a museum tour.

  • Correct people on art facts (even when wrong).

  • Look mildly horrified any time someone touches anything.

Quirks:

  • Carries sanitizer “for artifacts.”

  • Collects odd things (stamps, thimbles, suspicions).

  • Gently dusts off nearby furniture while talking.

Sayings:

“I only collect originals… and impeccable excuses.”
“Art should be appreciated, not handled.”
“Some call it obsessive. I call it preservation.”

🖌️ The Forger – The Imitation Genius

Vibe: Brilliant, confident, and just a little too defensive. Creates perfect replicas — and perfectly believable stories.

Costume (from your closet):

  • Roll-sleeve shirt, vest or smock, dark jeans, messy hair.

  • Add small “paint” stains or smudges for effect.

Props & Accessories:

  • Paint palette, fake brushes, clipboard labeled “Reference Copy.”

  • Magnifying glass, sketchpad, or rolled-up “canvas.”

How to Act:

  • Compliment everyone’s “original” style.

  • Talk in detail about brushstrokes and techniques.

  • Get nervous when authenticity is mentioned.

Quirks:

  • Says “trust me” too often.

  • Keeps glancing at other artists’ work like they’re memorizing it.

  • Claims to have “restored” things that never needed it.

Sayings:

“It’s not fake — it’s faithful.”
“Inspiration is just borrowing with confidence.”
“Forgery? Such an ugly word. I prefer… recreation.”

🍎 The Art Teacher – The Encouraging Tornado

Vibe: Energetic, inspiring, and two brushstrokes away from a meltdown. The kind of person who believes every mess is a masterpiece.

Costume (from your closet):

  • Apron, colorful shirt, and jeans.

  • Add a splash of “paint” for realism.

  • Bright scarf or glasses optional.

Props & Accessories:

  • Paintbrushes, water cup, palette, clipboard labeled “Lesson Plan (Optional).”

  • Stack of crumpled “student art.”

How to Act:

  • Speak in bursts of inspiration.

  • Clap dramatically to start conversations.

  • Encourage everyone… even the suspects.

Quirks:

  • Forgets what they were saying mid-sentence.

  • Refers to the murder scene as “a learning moment.”

  • Accidentally turns everything into a metaphor.

Sayings:

“There are no mistakes — only unexpected color choices!”
“Your motive could use more contrast.”
“You’re all doing wonderfully. Terrifyingly, but wonderfully.”

🧥 Quick Recap – What’s Probably Already in Your Closet:

You don’t need a gallery to dress like one!
Here’s your DIY checklist for any Art World role:

  • Blazer or jacket

  • Black jeans or neutral pants

  • Scarf or statement accessory

  • Glasses (real or fake)

  • Notebook or sketchpad

  • Paintbrush, pen, or clipboard

  • Shoes with “main character energy”

🎭 Acting Tricks for All Art World Characters:

  • Always have a dramatic pause ready.

  • Treat every object like it might be priceless.

  • Use your hands when you talk — the bigger, the better.

  • When in doubt, say: “It’s symbolic.”

  • If accused, respond calmly with: “Ah. Interpretation.”

 Join our community for the latest mysteries, exclusive deals from the mother ship, and behind-the-scenes looks.

  • X
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • Facebook

© 2006. My Mystery Party, LLC. All rights reserved. Games created by Dr. Bon Blossman.

bottom of page
colorLinks("#0000FF"); function colorLinks(hex) { var links = document.getElementsByTagName("a"); for(var i=0;i