top of page

Costume Advice

WANDS & WHIMSY COSTUMES

Whether you're the high priestess of the coven or the mysterious warlock who "definitely isn’t cursed," it’s time to dress the part, stir the cauldron, and charm your party guests—literally.

This guide is your go-to spellbook for crafting the perfect look for witches and warlocks at your murder mystery party. No need to conjure up a full wardrobe from another realm—most of what you need might already be lurking in your closet (or your weird aunt’s attic).

From hair and makeup to spooky props and how to walk into a room like you’ve already cast a glamour spell, we’ve got you covered—whether you’re going for creepy, classy, or completely chaotic.

Wands up, let’s get wicked.

EXAMPLES OF WITCHY AND WARLOCKY COSTUMES

Character Role Ideas (Witchy & Warlock Types):

  • The Coveted Coven Queen

  • The Reformed Warlock (…or is he?)

  • The Potion Mastermind

  • The Crystal Clairvoyant

  • The Wand Shop Keeper

  • The Glam Witch Influencer

  • The Bookish Librarian of Lost Spells

  • The Moon Priestess or Shadow Prophet

  • The Cursed Romantic

Things You Might Already Own

Witches:

  • Black dress or maxi skirt

  • Chunky jewelry (bonus if it’s celestial or vintage)

  • Boots or pointed flats

  • Shawl or blanket scarf (aka instant cloak)

  • Oversized hat (witch hat DIY with felt!)

Warlocks:

  • Button-down shirts in dark colors

  • Dress pants or cargo-style trousers

  • Long cardigan or bathrobe as a “cloak”

  • Gloves, vests, or belts

  • Any staff-like item (umbrella, walking stick)

Hair & Makeup Ideas

Witches:

  • Loose waves, braids with ribbons or beads

  • Glittery highlight + dark lipstick

  • Smoky eye or metallic shadow

  • Star, moon, or rune face gems

Warlocks:

  • Slicked back, tousled, or tied hair

  • Smudged liner or dark eyeshadow (optional edge)

  • Light shimmer or contouring

  • Styled facial hair if applicable

Accessories & Props

  • Spell books (real or fake)

  • Potion bottles (reuse perfume bottles or vials)

  • Wand, staff, broomstick, or orb

  • Crystal necklaces, cuffs, rings, pins

  • Familiar props: plush cat, crow, snake, or lizard

  • Candles (battery-powered for safety)

Behavior: How to Act the Role

Vibe It Up:

  • Use elegant, intentional gestures—like you’re casting a spell with every wrist flick.

  • Pause dramatically before speaking (as if channeling energy or sensing lies).

  • Give sly smiles, cryptic glances, and sudden shifts in tone.

  • Don’t explain everything—let them wonder.

Voice & Diction Tips:

  • Go slow and smooth for mystical vibes, or theatrical and booming if you’re the coven leader.

  • Add a faint accent (British, Romanian, or invent your own).

  • Use words like “alas,” “beware,” or “it is foretold…”

  • Bonus: whisper your secrets. Loud whispers = peak drama.

 Join our community for the latest mysteries, exclusive deals from the mother ship, and behind-the-scenes looks.

  • X
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • Facebook

© 2006. My Mystery Party, LLC. All rights reserved. Games created by Dr. Bon Blossman.

bottom of page
colorLinks("#0000FF"); function colorLinks(hex) { var links = document.getElementsByTagName("a"); for(var i=0;i