top of page

Costume Advice

WANDS & WHIMSY COSTUMES

Whether you're the high priestess of the coven or the mysterious warlock who "definitely isn’t cursed," it’s time to dress the part, stir the cauldron, and charm your party guests—literally.

This guide is your go-to spellbook for crafting the perfect look for witches and warlocks at your murder mystery party. No need to conjure up a full wardrobe from another realm—most of what you need might already be lurking in your closet (or your weird aunt’s attic).

From hair and makeup to spooky props and how to walk into a room like you’ve already cast a glamour spell, we’ve got you covered—whether you’re going for creepy, classy, or completely chaotic.

Wands up, let’s get wicked.

EXAMPLES OF WITCHY AND WARLOCKY COSTUMES

Character Role Ideas (Witchy & Warlock Types):

  • The Coveted Coven Queen

  • The Reformed Warlock (…or is he?)

  • The Potion Mastermind

  • The Crystal Clairvoyant

  • The Wand Shop Keeper

  • The Glam Witch Influencer

  • The Bookish Librarian of Lost Spells

  • The Moon Priestess or Shadow Prophet

  • The Cursed Romantic

THE WITCH – The Crafty Spellcaster

Vibe: Mystical, mischievous, and one minor inconvenience away from placing a curse on the entire group chat.

DIY Look

  • Wear a black dress, skirt, leggings, or dark jeans with a dramatic blouse.

  • Add a shawl, cape, lace cardigan, or velvet jacket.

  • Layer necklaces, rings, scarves, and anything involving moons or crystals.

  • Use dark eyeliner, smoky shadow, and deep red, purple, or black lipstick.

  • Add green makeup only if you’re embracing full storybook witch.

  • Tease your hair, braid it, or wear it loose and wild.

  • Finish with a pointed hat—or skip it for a more modern “suburban coven” look.

Accessories

  • Broom, preferably one that looks incapable of actual flight.

  • Small cauldron filled with candy or suspicious ingredients.

  • Wand made from a painted stick.

  • Old book labeled “SPELLS & RECEIPTS.”

  • Bottles filled with colored water and dramatic labels.

  • Crystals, tarot cards, herbs, or a battery-operated candle.

  • Wooden spoon for aggressively stirring invisible potions.

How to Act

  • Whisper strange words while pointing at inconvenient people.

  • Blame every technological failure on Mercury retrograde.

  • Stir drinks as though secretly brewing something.

  • Examine people’s palms without being asked.

  • Refer to gossip as “a message from the universe.”

  • Threaten minor curses for cutting in line or taking the last snack.

  • Describe the murder as “dark magic with poor execution.”

  • Enter rooms by announcing, “The coven has arrived.”

Quirks

  • Claims to sense bad energy—but usually just dislikes someone.

  • Consults tarot cards for extremely basic decisions.

  • Collects ordinary objects and calls them potion ingredients.

  • Keeps losing the wand currently tucked behind their ear.

  • Insists the broom is decorative because their license was suspended.

Sayings

  • “I’m not bossy. I’m coven-appointed.”

  • “Careful—my patience is hex-piring.”

  • “That alibi needs a stronger spell.”

  • “I don’t curse everyone. Some people earn it.”

  • “The cards warned me about this party.”

  • “Is it witchcraft—or am I simply better than you?”

  • “I came, I saw, I made it weird.”

  • “My broomstick has more horsepower than your car.”

  • “The victim had terrible energy.”

  • “Don’t test me. I brought the good cauldron.”

🧙 THE WIZARD – The Questionably Qualified Sorcerer

Vibe: Wise, theatrical, and dangerously confident for someone whose spells only work about half the time.

DIY Look

  • Wear a long robe, oversized cardigan, velvet jacket, or belted blanket.

  • Choose deep blue, purple, gray, black, or anything covered in stars.

  • Add a scarf, cape, or dramatic fabric draped over your shoulders.

  • Wear boots or pointed slippers.

  • Create a beard with costume hair, cotton batting, or sheer determination.

  • Finish with a pointed hat—or claim you’ve transcended hats.

Accessories

  • Wand made from a painted stick or wooden spoon.

  • Staff decorated with ribbon, crystals, or battery-operated lights.

  • Old book labeled “SPELLS I MOSTLY REMEMBER.”

  • Pouch of “magical stones.”

  • Tiny bottles filled with colored water.

  • Hourglass, crystal ball, or glitter-filled ornament.

  • Reading glasses for interpreting ancient enchantments.

How to Act

  • Speak as though every sentence is an ancient prophecy.

  • Wave your wand at ordinary problems.

  • Pause dramatically before giving obvious advice.

  • Refer to technology as “forbidden machinery.”

  • Blame failed spells on atmospheric interference.

  • Call the murder “a disturbance in the mystical realm.”

  • Give everyone elaborate wizard names they didn’t request.

  • Announce “Stand back!” before doing absolutely nothing.

Quirks

  • Forgets spell words halfway through casting.

  • Claims every coincidence was intentional magic.

  • Consults the spell book but always holds it upside down.

  • Collects ordinary rocks and insists they contain power.

  • Becomes defensive when anyone mentions magicians.

Sayings

  • “I’m not late. Wizards arrive after the appetizers.”

  • “That alibi reeks of dark magic.”

  • “Stand back—I almost know what I’m doing.”

  • “I foresaw this. Just not accurately.”

  • “My powers are stronger after coffee.”

  • “Do not question the robe.”

  • “That spell usually works indoors.”

  • “The crystal ball has terrible reception.”

  • “Murder? I sensed a disturbance—and heard screaming.”

  • “A true wizard never reveals his secrets. Mostly because he forgot them.”

🔮 THE FORTUNE TELLER - PSYCHIC

Vibe: Mystical, dramatic, and always technically correct—as long as nobody asks for specifics.

DIY Look

  • Wear a flowing skirt, wide-leg pants, or a loose dress in rich jewel tones.

  • Add a dramatic shawl, scarf, kimono, or velvet jacket.

  • Layer necklaces, rings, bangles, and oversized earrings.

  • Choose deep purple, burgundy, emerald, midnight blue, or gold.

  • Add smoky eye makeup, glitter, or dark lipstick.

  • Wrap a scarf around your hair or wear a decorative headband.

  • Carry yourself like you already know everyone’s secrets.

Accessories

  • Crystal ball—or a clear ornament balanced on a candleholder.

  • Tarot cards or a homemade deck of mysterious symbols.

  • Small table covered with a patterned scarf.

  • Battery-operated candles and strands of fairy lights.

  • Notebook labeled “OMINOUS PREDICTIONS.”

  • Velvet pouch filled with coins, charms, or polished stones.

  • Magnifying glass for examining unusually complicated palms.

How to Act

  • Stare deeply into someone’s eyes before answering simple questions.

  • Study palms and react as though you’ve discovered something alarming.

  • Predict events immediately after they happen.

  • Begin statements with “The spirits are telling me…”

  • Give vague warnings that could apply to absolutely anyone.

  • Call the murder “a dark turn in the cosmic path.”

  • Shuffle cards whenever the conversation becomes uncomfortable.

  • Blame incorrect predictions on someone’s negative energy.

Quirks

  • Gasps dramatically at completely ordinary tarot cards.

  • Claims the crystal ball is cloudy due to poor spiritual reception.

  • Accepts payment in cash because the spirits don’t use credit.

  • Predicts that someone will “face a difficult choice” near the dessert table.

  • Refuses to reveal lottery numbers for ethical reasons.

Sayings

  • “I see danger in your future—and something involving cheese.”

  • “The spirits are vague, but extremely concerned.”

  • “Your palm says you’re hiding something.”

  • “I predicted this. Just not out loud.”

  • “The cards never lie. I occasionally interpret creatively.”

  • “Your future is cloudy. Have you tried turning it off and back on?”

  • “I sense betrayal…or indigestion.”

  • “The victim’s energy has become unusually quiet.”

  • “Ask me anything—except for exact dates.”

  • “Your alibi has a very troubling aura.”

 Join our community for the latest mysteries, exclusive deals from the mother ship, and behind-the-scenes looks.

  • X
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • Facebook

© 2006. My Mystery Party, LLC. All rights reserved. Games created by Dr. Bon Blossman.

bottom of page
colorLinks("#0000FF"); function colorLinks(hex) { var links = document.getElementsByTagName("a"); for(var i=0;i