Unleash the mystery. Live the story.
Costume Advice
STUFFING & SUSPICION COSTUME GUIDE
Fall vibes. Killer alibis.
Whether you're rocking corduroy pants or full pilgrim cosplay you ordered ironically, this Thanksgiving-themed costume guide gives you everything you need to be festive, chaotic, and slightly suspicious. All you need is something vaguely autumnal… and one prop that makes people giggle.
From sweet potatoes to side-eyes — let’s serve.
TURKEY-WORTHY COSTUME LOOKS
The Cousin Who Came for Drama, Not Dinner
Closet staples: Leopard print + burnt orange = fall fight club
Footwear: Heeled boots for stomping out of arguments
Hair/Makeup: Slick ponytail, smoky eye, lip color called “Stuffing Me Softly”
Accessories: Giant sunglasses, purse full of passive aggression
Prop: A “pumpkin spice lie detector” (aka a glittery notebook)
Behavior: Starts sentences with “I’m just saying...” then drops truth bombs
Phrases:
-
“Oh, I thought this was a real mystery party.”
-
“We all know who didn’t bring a side dish.”
-
“I’m not here to make friends. I’m here to win charades.”
The Unhinged Turkey
Closet staples: Brown hoodie + feathers hot glued to your pride
Footwear: Orange socks over your shoes = talons, babe
Hair/Makeup: Red blush dabbed down your neck = gobbler chic
Accessories: Feathers, glitter, cardboard beak (or just vibe)
Prop: Giant fork with “NOT TODAY” written on it
Behavior: Gobbles when nervous. Occasionally sprints.
Phrases:
-
“You thought I was pardoned.”
-
“Catch me in gravy or not at all.”
-
“Stuff THIS.”
The Side Dish with a Dark Secret
Closet staples: Green, beige, and mystery — aka Grandma’s casserole
Footwear: Flats with questionable stains
Hair/Makeup: Frosted eyeshadow and a tight-lipped smile
Accessories: Recipe card with scribbled-out ingredients
Prop: Pyrex dish with a plastic clue hidden in mashed potatoes
Behavior: Hovers near the buffet. Knows too much.
Phrases:
-
“It’s a family recipe. That’s all you need to know.”
-
“Let’s just say… someone didn’t preheat the oven.”
-
“I seasoned more than just the stuffing.”
The Autumn-Wrapped Influencer
Closet staples: Oversized flannel, thigh-high boots, Insta-ready hat
Footwear: Anything suede, anything impractical
Hair/Makeup: Loose waves, over-blushed cheeks, dewy highlight
Accessories: Apple cider, aesthetic mug, decorative throw blanket
Prop: Mini chalkboard sign that says “grateful-ish”
Behavior: Narrates her outfit and motives for a nonexistent TikTok
Phrases:
-
“Today’s fit is sponsored by unresolved tension and Trader Joe’s.”
-
“Tag yourself, I’m the cinnamon stick.”
-
“Is this giving murder?”
The Mysterious Grandparent Who May Be Immortal
Closet staples: Knitted sweater, loafers, possibly a quilt cape
Footwear: Loafers. Always loafers.
Hair/Makeup: Wispy white wig, suspicious twinkle
Accessories: Brooch, glasses on a chain, hot tea and hard truths
Prop: Folded newspaper with cryptic notes in the margins
Behavior: Says creepy but accurate things. Might vanish.
Phrases:
-
“I’ve seen this before… in ‘62.”
-
“That gravy boat isn’t from this century.”
-
“Death comes to the inattentive.”
Thanksgiving Prop Ideas for Laughs
-
Giant fake wishbone with “WHO BROKE IT?” scribbled on it
-
Pilgrim hat… but make it rhinestoned
-
A tray of “evidence” labeled as leftovers
-
Felt leaves you drop dramatically like a trail
-
A glittery sign that says “IT WAS THE YAMS”
Add an accessory to your costume: if you are playing a Thanksgiving game and have your costume that fits your character's occupation, you can always add a fun pumpkin pie or turkey hat to be festive and get some laughs.
Skip your character-themed costume and wear a fun Thanksgiving costume: with any of the Thanksgiving games, you could also certainly opt to wear a Thanksgiving themed costume instead of the theme of your character's occupation. It's all about making others laugh and having a blast, so if you want to suit up in a turkey costume or go to the party dressed as a big corn on the cob - please, by all means, do it! You can note your character with the name tag.